MoneyTurkey data page for the Blindspot deep dive “The Commoditisation of High Tech“. Data cut-off 11 November 2026; market prices and filings rechecked to 15 November 2026 (London). Research, not investment advice.
Money convention: dollar figures appear as originally reported (nominal), with the 2026-dollar equivalent alongside. The deflator is the BLS CPI-U (all items, not seasonally adjusted; FRED CPIAUCNS): the October 2026 reading of 337.511 divided by the annual-average CPI of the year the price applies to. Before 1913 the series is the Minneapolis Fed’s historical CPI table (Minneapolis Fed), chain-linked to CPI-U at 1913; the Minneapolis Fed calls pre-1913 values estimates. The 2025 average uses 11 months, because BLS did not publish October 2025. Multi-year totals are converted at a stated single year. Figures already dated 2026 are not converted; sterling and euro figures are not converted.
A. Effect on national economies, boom and bust
| Episode | Boom footprint | Bust | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK Railway Mania | Rail investment ~£44m in 1847, ~7% of GDP; Mitchell estimates 5.7% (1846), 6.7% (1847), 4.7% (1848) | Share collapse after 1845–47; investment fell back sharply after 1848 | 1, 2 |
| US railroads, 1873 | Post-Civil War rail building | NBER contraction Oct 1873–Mar 1879, 65 months (longest on record) | 3 |
| US railroads, 1893 | Second rail boom of the 1880s | NBER contractions Jan 1893–Jun 1894 (17 months) and Dec 1895–Jun 1897 (18 months); 27,000+ miles in receivership in 1893 | 3, 4 |
| Cars and the 1920s | Mass-production boom; Ford at 50% of the US market by October 1922 | NBER contraction Aug 1929–Mar 1933 (43 months); producers fell from 272 (1909) to 9 (1941) | 5, 3, 6 |
| Telecom and dot-com | >$500bn telecom capex 1996–2001 (~$1tn in 2026 dollars); IT equipment and software investment 4.46% of GDP in Q4 2000 | NBER recession Mar–Nov 2001; IT investment share fell to 3.40% by Q4 2005; ~$2tn shareholder losses (~$3.8tn in 2026 dollars); ~500,000 telecom jobs lost | 7, 8 |
| AI (2023–26) | IT equipment and software investment 5.35% of GDP in Q3 2026, above the 2000 peak; Furman: these categories were 92% of US GDP growth in H1 2025 | None to date | 8, 9 |
The railway comparison is of the same order of magnitude but on a different base: Victorian GDP estimates are uncertain, and Odlyzko gives a £460–600 million range 10.
B. Index membership: who came in, who went out
| Date | Index event | Reading | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1884 | Dow’s first average: 11 stocks, 9 of them railroads | The technology of the day was the index | 11 |
| 26 May 1896 | Dow Jones Industrial Average launched with 12 industrials (e.g. General Electric, US Rubber) | Industrials split off from rails | 12 |
| 16 Mar 1915 | General Motors enters the Dow | Cars arrive | 12 |
| 14 Mar 1939 | AT&T and United Aircraft replace Nash-Kelvinator and IBM | A shakeout car maker leaves; telecoms and aviation enter (IBM returns in 1979) | 12 |
| 29 Jun 1979 | IBM and Merck replace Chrysler and Esmark | Computing replaces a weakened car maker | 12 |
| 1 Nov 1999 | Microsoft and Intel (the first Nasdaq stocks in the Dow), SBC and Home Depot enter | The PC era enters near the dot-com top | 12 |
| 8 Apr 2004 | AT&T leaves the Dow | Telecom after the bust | 12 |
| 8 Jun 2009 | Cisco replaces General Motors (in bankruptcy) | The car shakeout finishes in the index | 12 |
| 24 Dec 2012 | Research In Motion (BlackBerry) leaves the Nasdaq-100 | Handset shakeout | 13 |
| 19 Mar 2015 | Apple replaces AT&T in the Dow | Mobile winner in, incumbent telco out | 14 |
| 8 Nov 2024 | Nvidia replaces Intel in the Dow | 25 years after Intel’s entry, the AI supplier replaces the PC-era chip leader | 15 |
Weights tell the same story. Railroads went from 63% of US market value in 1900 to under 1% by 2017. IT was about 33% of the S&P 500 at the March 2000 peak and fell back to mid-teens weights in the early 2000s 16.
Not shown: a full list of S&P 500 additions and deletions by sector across 1999–2003, and cap-weighted railroad market share by decade. Neither is available from free public sources.
C. Index and sector prices through each cycle
The broad market over 140 years. Chart 9 in the article shows the Dow from 1885 (Dow’s earlier average until the Dow Jones Industrial Average launched on 26 May 1896) to 9 November 2026, on a log scale, nominal and in 2026 dollars. Every technology bust is visible. The table gives peak-to-trough falls on daily closes 17.
| Dow episode | Peak → trough (nominal) | Fall, nominal | Back to peak, nominal | Fall / back to peak, in 2026 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1893 rail panic | 4 Jun 1890 → 8 Aug 1896 | −47% | Jan 1899 (8.6 yrs) | −45% / Aug 1898 (8.2 yrs) |
| 1906–07 | 19 Jan 1906 → 15 Nov 1907 | −49% | Jul 1915 (9.5 yrs) | −50% / Sep 1915 (9.7 yrs) |
| 1929–32 | 3 Sep 1929 → 8 Jul 1932 | −89% | 23 Nov 1954 (25.2 yrs) | −86% / May 1959 (29.7 yrs) |
| 1973–74 | 11 Jan 1973 → 6 Dec 1974 | −45% | Nov 1982 (9.8 yrs) | −68% (low Aug 1982) / Jul 1993 (20.5 yrs) |
| 2000–02 (dot-com and telecom) | 14 Jan 2000 → 9 Oct 2002 | −38% | Oct 2006 (6.7 yrs) | −56% (low Mar 2009) / Dec 2013 (13.9 yrs) |
| 2007–09 | 9 Oct 2007 → 9 Mar 2009 | −54% | Mar 2013 (5.4 yrs) | −55% / Nov 2013 (6.1 yrs) |
| AI era to date | 30 Nov 2022 close 34,589.77 → 13 Nov 2026 close 52,347.55 | +51% | — | +33% in 2026 dollars |
The 1873 panic predates the series; it appears in the railroad chart (chart 1). Inflation matters most in the 1970s: the nominal Dow regained its 1973 level in 1982, but in 2026 dollars it took until 1993.
Sector indices. Free sector data are thinner than broad-index data. The table and charts 10–14 use what is free: NYSE Arca and Nasdaq sector indices and ETFs from Yahoo Finance (price only, from the 1990s), share prices for the handset makers, and Kenneth French’s industry portfolios for 1926–2026, which include dividends.
| Cycle | Price path | Drawdown | Time to recover | Basis | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| US railroad stocks, 1872–77 | Peak Apr 1872 → trough Jun 1877 | −48% | — | price | 18 |
| US railroad stocks, 1892–96 | Peak Mar 1892 → trough Aug 1896 | −33% | — | price | 18 |
| US railroad stocks, 1906–07 | Peak Sep 1906 → trough Nov 1907 | −35% | — | price | 18 |
| US railroad stocks, 1929–32 | Peak Sep 1929 → trough Jun 1932 | −91% | Did not recover within the series (ends 1937) | price | 18 |
| Transport stocks (railroads, airlines, trucking), 1929–32 | Aug 1929 → Jun 1932 | −91% | Dec 1950 (21.3 yrs); 23.4 yrs in 2026 dollars | total return | 19 |
| Auto stocks, 1929–32 | Feb 1929 → Jun 1932 | −90% | Sep 1936 (7.6 yrs) | total return | 19 |
| Auto stocks, 1999–2009 | Apr 1999 → Feb 2009 | −77% (−82% real) | Jul 2013 (14.3 yrs); 18.8 yrs in 2026 dollars | total return | 19 |
| Electronic equipment incl. chips, 1929–32 | Jun 1929 → Jun 1932 | −96% | Mar 1944 (14.7 yrs) | total return | 19 |
| Electronic equipment incl. chips, 2000–02 | Mar 2000 → Sep 2002 | −84% | Oct 2017 (17.6 yrs); 19.8 yrs in 2026 dollars | total return | 19 |
| Telecom stocks, 2000–02 | Mar 2000 → Sep 2002 | −72% | Dec 2013 (13.8 yrs); 19.3 yrs in 2026 dollars | total return | 19 |
| Airlines: NYSE Arca Airline Index | 192 (Mar 1998, on Yahoo’s rebased series; roughly double that on the basis quoted at the time, inferred from LA Times, 3 Sep 1998 20) → 14.4 (Mar 2009) | −93% | Not regained (69.4 in Nov 2026) | price, month-end | 21 |
| Airlines: U.S. Global Jets ETF, 2018–20 | Jan 2018 → Mar 2020 | −54% | Jun 2026 (8.4 yrs) | adjusted close | 22 |
| Chipmakers: PHLX Semiconductor Index | 1,182 (Mar 2000) → 239 (Sep 2002) → 198 (Nov 2008) | −80% / −83% | Oct 2017 (17.6 yrs) | price, month-end | 23 |
| Chipmakers: PHLX Semiconductor Index, AI era | 2,827 (Nov 2022) → 14,247 (Jun 2026) → 9,998 (10 Nov 2026) | +404% Nov 2022 → Jun 2026; −30% from Jun 2026; +254% net since Nov 2022 | — | price, month-end | 23 |
| Telecom: Nasdaq Telecommunications Index | 1,141 (Feb 2000) → 88 (Sep 2002) | −92% | Not regained (507 in Nov 2026) | price, month-end | 24 |
| Handsets: Nokia (US-listed shares) | Apr 2000 → Jun 2012 | −95% | Not regained | adjusted close | 25 |
| Handsets: BlackBerry / Research In Motion | May 2008 → Oct 2024 | −98% | Not regained | adjusted close | 26 |
| Nasdaq Composite, 2000–02 | 5,048.62 (10 Mar 2000) → 1,114.11 (9 Oct 2002) | −78% | ~15 years (23 Apr 2015) | price, daily | 27 |
| Nvidia, 27 Jan 2025 (DeepSeek day) | $142.62 (24 Jan 2025) → $118.42 (27 Jan 2025) | −17%; $589–593bn (~$618–622bn in 2026 dollars) | First close above $142.62 on 9 Jun 2025; record $154.31 on 25 Jun 2025; $162.85 on 13 Nov 2026 (~$3.9tn) | price, daily | 28, 29, 30, 31 |
D. The product’s price collapse
| Technology | From (nominal; 2026 dollars) | To (nominal; 2026 dollars) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ford Model T | $850 (1908); ~$31,900 | As low as $260 (early 1920s); ~$5,000 at 1925 prices | 5, 32 |
| New vehicles, US CPI relative to all-items CPI | 1950 average | −67% by 2025 (quality-adjusted index) | 33 |
| US domestic itinerary fare, inflation-adjusted (BTS) | $618 (1995, in 2025 dollars); ~$648 | $387 (2025); ~$406 | 34 |
| US domestic airfares incl. fees, real (A4A) | 1978 | “Nearly 50%” lower | 35 |
| US domestic yield (revenue per passenger-mile), real | 1978 | −2.0% a year to 1988, −1.9% a year for 23 years after; ~−47% by 2011 (author’s calc.) | 36 |
| Computer memory, real $ per TB | ~$1.05m (2000, in 2020 dollars); ~$1.36m | ~$1,088 (2023, in 2020 dollars); ~$1,420 | 37 |
| IP transit, $ per Mbps per month | $1,200 (1998); ~$2,480 | $0.63 (2015); ~$0.90 | 38 |
| LLM inference at a fixed capability | — | 9× to 900× cheaper per year depending on task (median 50×) | 39 |
Measurement note on airfares. Fares actually paid (A4A, from the DOT ticket survey plus fees) and real yield (Borenstein and Rose) agree on a fall of roughly half since 1978; BTS itinerary fares, which start in 1995, show −37.3% to 2025. The CPI airline-fare index agrees with BTS from 1995 (−36%) but shows a 14% real rise over 1978–2025, because until shortly before 1994 it priced unrestricted full fares that few passengers paid 40 and it carries an upward bias 41. The text uses the fares-paid and yield measures. Airfares stay out of chart 2, because no free annual 1978–95 series was charted.
E. Firm counts and consolidation
| Industry | Peak count / fragmentation | After the shakeout | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| US car producers | 272 (1909) | 9 (1941); top three >80% of output by the 1930s | 42 |
| US railroads | — | 27,000+ miles in receivership in 1893; 40,503 miles foreclosed 1894–98 | 4 |
| US airlines | 198 bankruptcy filings, 1979–Feb 2016 | Four carriers ~85% of passengers (2013) | 43, 44 |
| DRAM | Top ten ~80% (1995) | Three firms >90% (2013–14); 90.5% in Q4 2025 (Samsung 36.0%, SK Hynix 32.1%, Micron 22.4%) | 45, 46 |
| Leading-edge chipmakers | 29 (2001) | 6 (c. 2016) | 45 |
| US IPO window (dot-com) | 476 IPOs (1999), 380 (2000) | 80 (2001), 66 (2002), 63 (2003) | 47 |
| Smartphones | Nokia 49.4% of world sales (2007) | Nokia devices sold to Microsoft (2013); $7.6bn write-down (2015) | 48, 49 |
F. Caveats and data licences
Caveats. The railroad series, the Dow, the Nasdaq Composite and the NYSE Arca, PHLX and Nasdaq sector indices are price indices. Dividends were a large part of returns, especially for railroads and telecoms, so their price drawdowns overstate total-return losses. The French portfolios include dividends; they are free to download but built from CRSP data, and their industry groups are broader than the trading indices (“Chips” covers all electronic equipment; “Trans” mixes railroads, airlines and trucking). Yahoo month-end closes understate intramonth extremes. Index constituents change, so failed members drop out and the indices flatter survivors. Motorola is left out of the handset chart because its listed history (now Motorola Solutions) is distorted by the 2011 spin-off of Motorola Mobility.
Checks. Yahoo’s PHLX Semiconductor month-end closes match Nasdaq’s own published history to within 0.2% from 1997. MeasuringWorth’s Dow matches the public-domain NBER Macrohistory Dow (1897–1916, via FRED) after MeasuringWorth’s stated 36% splice: the 1906–07 fall is −44% against −43.5% on monthly averages.
Data licences. Several series have no free source that may be republished. Yahoo Finance’s terms bar reproduction and commercial use, and Nasdaq requires a licence to redistribute historical PHLX Semiconductor, Nasdaq Telecommunications and Nasdaq Composite values from any source. MeasuringWorth allows non-profit educational use with credit, and the French library states no licence. No comparable public-domain series exists, so the data stay unchanged and carry the attribution each source asks for. That works for a non-monetised first issue; a monetised issue would need permission or a licence for charts 6 and 9–14.
Not shown: daily total-return sector indices before 1926, an airline-only index before 1992 and the history of the Dow Jones Internet Composite Index. None is available from free public sources.
Sources
- Odlyzko, 2010, hallucinations.pdf.
- Campbell, 2013, RailwayDeriving.pdf.
- NBER, US business cycle expansions and contractions, nber.org.
- Stuart Daggett, Railroad Reorganization, 1908, gutenberg.org.
- The Henry Ford, “Ford’s Model T”, thehenryford.org.
- Steven Klepper, NBER conference paper on the US automobile industry, 2009, nber.org.
- Robert E. Litan, “The Telecommunications Crash: What To Do Now”, Brookings, December 2002, brookings.edu.
- BEA via FRED, private fixed investment in information-processing equipment and software (A679RC1Q027SBEA), author’s ratio to GDP, A679RC1Q027SBEA; GDP.
- Fortune, October 2025 (Jason Furman), fortune.com.
- Odlyzko, £460–600 million range for the railway comparison, mania04.pdf.
- Library of Congress, Dow Jones Industrial Average business history, loc.gov.
- Dow member history (Wall Street Journal / CME), wsj.com.
- Nasdaq, annual changes to the Nasdaq-100 Index (Research In Motion departure, December 2012), ir.nasdaq.com.
- S&P Dow Jones Indices, “Apple Set to Join the Dow Jones Industrial Average”, 2015, spglobal.com.
- S&P Dow Jones Indices, Nvidia replaces Intel in the Dow, 1 November 2024, spglobal.com.
- CME Group OpenMarkets, “What Past Sector Concentrations Tell Us About Today’s Tech-Heavy S&P 500”, 2026, cmegroup.com.
- Samuel H. Williamson, “Daily Closing Value of the Dow Jones Average, 1885 to Present,” MeasuringWorth, 2026, author’s calculation, deflated with CPI-U and the Minneapolis Fed table, measuringworth.com/DJA.
- NBER Macrohistory m11005 (Macaulay) via FRED (M11005USM293NNBR), author’s calculation, fred.stlouisfed.org.
- Kenneth R. French Data Library, 49 Industry Portfolios (value-weighted), author’s calculation, dartmouth.edu.
- Los Angeles Times, Amex airline index at 274.14 on 3 September 1998, published 4 September 1998, latimes.com.
- Yahoo Finance, NYSE Arca Airline Index history, author’s calculation, finance.yahoo.com.
- Yahoo Finance, U.S. Global Jets ETF history, finance.yahoo.com.
- Yahoo Finance, PHLX Semiconductor Index history, author’s calculation, finance.yahoo.com.
- Yahoo Finance, Nasdaq Telecommunications Index history, author’s calculation, finance.yahoo.com.
- Yahoo Finance, Nokia history, author’s calculation, finance.yahoo.com.
- Yahoo Finance, BlackBerry history, author’s calculation, finance.yahoo.com.
- FRED, NASDAQ Composite (NASDAQCOM), fred.stlouisfed.org.
- Reuters, “China’s DeepSeek sets off AI market rout”, 27 January 2025, reuters.com.
- CNBC, “Nvidia shares head for record close”, 25 June 2025, cnbc.com.
- Fund Library, Nvidia Corporation market details, fundlibrary.com.
- Yahoo Finance, Nvidia history, author’s check, finance.yahoo.com.
- The Henry Ford, Model T artifact note (artifact 74347), thehenryford.org.
- FRED, CPI for new vehicles (CUUR0000SETA01) and all-items CPI (CPIAUCNS), author’s calculation, CUUR0000SETA01; CPIAUCNS.
- Bureau of Transportation Statistics, 2025 annual average domestic air fare, April 2026, bts.gov.
- Airlines for America (A4A), “As air travel breaks record volumes, U.S. airfares fall to historic lows”, airlines.org.
- Severin Borenstein and Nancy Rose, NBER chapter on airline pricing and deregulation, nber.org.
- Our World in Data / J.C. McCallum, historical cost of computer memory and storage, ourworldindata.org.
- DrPeering, Internet transit prices, drpeering.net.
- Epoch AI, LLM inference price trends, epoch.ai.
- Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, Economic Review, 1994 Q2, dallasfed.org.
- Good, Sickles and Weiher, Review of Income and Wealth, 2008, doi.org.
- Steven Klepper, Revue de l’OFCE, 2006, ofce.fr.
- Airlines for America (A4A), unofficial compilation of US airline bankruptcies and service cessations, archived 28 May 2016, web.archive.org.
- US Government Accountability Office, GAO-14-515, Airline Competition, gao.gov.
- McKinsey, “Memory: Are challenges ahead?”, mckinsey.com.
- TrendForce, DRAM market and contract prices, February 2026, trendforce.com.
- Jay R. Ritter, University of Florida, IPO Statistics, ufl.edu.
- Gartner, worldwide smartphone sales to end users, 11 March 2009, pressebox.de.
- Microsoft, “Microsoft announces restructuring of phone hardware business”, 8 July 2015, microsoft.com.
